Date published: Jul 2021
SUERF Policy Brief, No 130
by Gabriele Galati (De Nederlandsche Bank),
Richhild Moessner (Bank for International Settlements and CESifo) and Maarten van Rooij (De Nederlandsche Bank)1
Keywords: Inflation expectations.
Download: SUERF Policy Brief, No 130 (0.5 MB)
With euro area HICP inflation and professionals’ long-term inflation expectations persistently below the ECB’s inflation aim, a key question for the ECB is whether long-term inflation expectations have de-anchored. While these concerns rely on evidence about expectations of financial markets participants and professional forecasters, little is known about the anchoring of firms’ and households’ expectations. Using data from a satellite survey of the DNB Household Survey, we show that long-term expectations held by Dutch households are not well anchored at the ECB’s inflation aim. Importantly, unlike market participants and professional forecasters, Dutch households appear to be concerned about higher, not lower inflation (or deflation), in the euro area in the long-run.
The Covid-19 pandemic caused a sharp contraction in global activity and a marked decline in inflation, in some instances even into negative territory. Especially in this environment, the effectiveness of monetary policy depends on inflation expectations being well-anchored to the central bank’s inflation aim. Inflation expectations are also playing a key role in the ongoing debate on monetary frameworks.2
Most of the evidence on inflation expectations is based on measures of expectations by market participants and professional forecasters. The policy debate has however increasingly turned its focus on the anchoring of expectations held by households and firms, given that next to financial markets and professional forecasters, they play an important role in the monetary transmission mechanism as well.3 Moreover, a growing research literature has examined the dynamics and drivers of inflation expectations by households and firms, particularly since the seminal work by Coibion and Gorodnichenko (2015).
However, there is still very little evidence on the anchoring of consumers’ long-term inflation expectations, particularly in the euro area. The main reason is that most available surveys of households provide information only on short-term inflation expectations, while long-term expectations are crucial for anchoring.
A satellite survey conducted by the DNB in the context of the Dutch Household Survey (DHS) contributes to filling this information gap. For this survey, around 2500 households answered questions about the levels and probability distributions of their short- and long-term inflation expectations for the Netherlands and the euro area. The survey allows gauging the effects of consumers’ characteristics – such as gender, education, age and income – on their long-term inflation expectations.
Survey participants were randomly assigned to four different groups. Half of the participants were asked questions about their expectations of HICP inflation in the euro area, while the other half were asked the same questions for HICP inflation in the Netherlands. For each of these two groups, half of the respondents were provided with information about actual inflation (in the euro area and in the Netherlands, respectively) and the ECB’s price stability aim.
The results of the survey – which was conducted in December 2019 – highlight that median long-term inflation expectations of Dutch households are 4%, 2 percentage points (pp) above the ECB’s inflation aim (Table 1).4 If we consider a measure of the anchoring of inflation expectations in terms of “level anchoring”, Dutch households’ long-term inflation expectations are not well anchored to the ECB’s inflation aim.5
Table 1: Mean and median of inflation expectations by consumers
Note: This table shows the cross-sectional mean and median of short-term (1 year ahead) and long-term (10 years ahead) point inflation expectations for the whole sample and across subgroups.
There is also evidence of high disagreement among respondents, as indicated by a high interquartile range (8 pp) of long-term inflation expectations. Moreover, Dutch households tend to be more concerned about risks of higher rather than lower inflation in the long run. This is evident from mean long-term inflation expectations being higher than median expectations, reflecting a positively skewed distribution of inflation expectations.
Importantly, long-term inflation expectations remain significantly above 2% even for survey participants that receive information about actual inflation and the ECB’s inflation aim (Table 1). Compared to those participants that do not receive this information, median long-term inflation expectations are 1pp lower (4% rather than 5%). As a result of the large cross-sectional variation the difference in mean long-term inflation expectations is statistically insignificant, while the difference in median long-term inflation expectations is statistically significant.
Using again the concept of level anchoring, the aggregate probability distributions of long-term inflation expectations provide further evidence that Dutch households’ long-term inflation expectations are not firmly anchored to the ECB’s inflation aim. The probability of future euro area inflation being in a range that is consistent with the ECB’s inflation aim, here assumed to be between 1% and 3%, is relatively low at 35% on average (Figure 1). Inflation rates which are more clearly (2pp or more) above the ECB’s inflation aim have a much higher probability, at 28% on average, than those of much lower inflation (2pp or more below the ECB’s inflation aim, i.e. of deflation), at 12%.
Figure 1: Average of consumers’ probability distributions of expected euro area inflation
This provides further evidence that the de-anchoring of long-term consumers’ inflation expectations is mainly due to expected higher inflation, rather than to expected lower inflation (or deflation). This contrasts with recent concerns about a possible de-anchoring of long-term inflation expectations on the downside, rather than on the upside.
Finally, we find that socio-economic factors can influence consumers’ inflation expectations. Long-term inflation expectations are better anchored for men, for older age, for higher education levels and for higher net household income. In other words, older, male, higher educated and higher income respondents report higher expected probabilities of the long-term of inflation being close to the ECB’s inflation aim, and lower probabilities of inflation being far above or below the ECB’s inflation aim.
Ball, L. and S. Mazumber (2011). “Inflation dynamics and the Great Recession”. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, Spring, 311-405.
Cœuré, B. (2019). “Inflation expectations and the conduct of monetary policy”. Speech at an event organised by the SAFE Policy Center, Frankfurt am Main, 11 July.
Coibion, O. and Gorodnichenko, Y. (2015). “Is the Phillips curve alive and well after all? Inflation expectations and the missing disinflation”. American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, 7(1), 197-232.
Galati, G., Moessner, R. and M. van Rooij (2020). “The anchoring of long-term inflation expectations of consumers: insights from a new survey”. DNB Working Paper, No. 688.
Galati, G., Moessner, R. and M. van Rooij (2021). “Anchoring of consumers’ long-term euro area inflation expectations during the pandemic.” DNB Working Paper No. 715.
Powell, T. and D. Wessel (2020). “What are inflation expectations? Why do they matter?”. Brookings Blog, 30 November.
Villeroy de Galhau (2019). “Household expectations”. Speech at the Joint Conference on Household Expectations, Frankfurt am Main, 28 July
Weidmann, J. (2019). “Expectations matter”. Welcoming remarks at the Joint Conference on Household Expectations, Frankfurt am Main, 26 July.
About the authors
Gabriele Galati is a senior policy advisor in the Economics and Research Division at De Nederlandsche Bank. He has previously worked as a (senior) economist and manager at the Bank for International Settlements. He holds a Ph.D. in Economics from New York University.
Richhild Moessner is a senior economist in the Monetary and Economic Department at the Bank for International Settlements, and also a CESifo research network fellow. Richhild has previously worked as a senior economist and manager at the Bank of England, as a senior economist in the ECB’s research department, and as a senior policy advisor at the Dutch Central Bank.
Maarten van Rooij is a senior research economist at the Economics and Research Division of De Nederlandsche Bank. He holds a Ph.D. in Economics from Utrecht University and his research focuses mainly on household surveys and household financial behavior. His papers have been published in for instance Journal of Financial Economics, The Economic Journal, Journal of Economic Psychology, International Journal of Central banking and Journal of Banking and Finance.
SUERF Policy Briefs (SPBs) serve to promote SUERF Members’ economic views and research findings as well as economic policy-oriented analyses. They address topical issues and propose solutions to current economic and financial challenges. SPBs serve to increase the international visibility of SUERF Members’ analyses and research. The views expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of the institution(s) the author(s).
Editorial Board: Ernest Gnan, Frank Lierman, David T. Llewellyn, Donato Masciandaro, Natacha Valla.
SUERF - The European Money and Finance Forum
A-1090 Vienna, Austria
www.suerf.org • email@example.com